Where am I?
Home > Chronicles > World > Europe
Saturday, November 21 2009 14:13h
TRIAL
French Court Sentences Four Over Queen Mary Deaths
The accident happened when construction workers and their families crowded on to the gangway during a weekend visit to the luxury liner.
French Court Sentences Four Over Queen Mary Deaths
The Newest Articles
photo: Reuters
Yves Violette, head of the Queen Mary 2 Victims Association, reacts after a court announced the verdict in the trial concerning victims of the Queen Mary 2 accident, in Rennes western France

Author
Author
Reuters
Photographer
Photo
Reuters
TEXT
Published: July 02, 2009 17:08h
Last modified: July 02, 2009 18:42h
A French court handed suspended prison sentences to four people and fined two firms over an accident in 2003 in which 16 people visiting the cruise liner Queen Mary II died when a gangway collapsed.

The accident happened when construction workers and their families crowded on to the gangway during a weekend visit to the luxury liner, which was nearing completion in dockyards in the French port of St Nazaire on the Atlantic coast.

The structure collapsed and people plunged more than 15 metres (45 feet) to the ground. Twenty-nine people were injured.

The court of appeal in Rennes imposed suspended sentences of two years on Fabien Bernal, a manager at the time at Endel, the company that built the faulty gangway, and Etienne Lamock, one of the supervisors in charge of the project at the dockyard.

It imposed 18-month suspended sentences on Loic Chauveau, the designer of the gangway, and Christophe Pierrard, who was in charge of installing it.

All four had been cleared in an earlier trial.

The appeal court also fined the two companies a maximum fine of 225,000 euros ($317,500) each, up from the 177,500 euros imposed by the lower court.

The companies have already been ordered to pay out some 10 million euros in civil suits.

"It's the decision the parties to the case were looking for," Olivier Guibert, a lawyer for a victim who lost both feet in the accident, told reporters. "This type of trial serves to help the grieving process."

Thierry Dalmasso, a lawyer for Endel, said he was bitterly disappointed by the ruling. "These disasters are not the product of a collection of faults by physical individuals but the sum product of a risk environment," he said.

The judge, explaining the sentences, commented on both the number of mistakes that had been made and their "extreme seriousness".

He ruled that a design fault had been the main factor behind the collapse of the gangway, which did not have diagonal bracing on the horizontal slats to ensure greater stability.

The judge also said the gangway had been installed "with no preliminary study, no calculations, no design, no weight details, which led to the absence of bracing".

Related Articles
ADS
EGYPT-ALGERIA DISPUTE

Mubarak's son weighs in on Egypt-Algeria dispute

The play-off came after Egypt defeated Algeria by two goals in Cairo on Saturday.
KOSOVO

Belgrade snubs Serbs who voted in Kosovo poll

Serbia refuses to recognise the independence of Kosovo, where 90 percent of the population...
HUMAN FAT

Peru accuses four of murder, selling human fat

The fat was purchased - to be commercialized in European (cosmetology) laboratories.
BOEING CRASHED IN MALI

Venezuelan drugs Boeing crashed in Mali

In July Guinea security forces discovered large quantities of chemicals used to produce...
LIFELINE

Child abuse may shorten cell lifeline

Earlier studies had shown that psychological stress elevates risk for a wide range of...
NEW SREBRENICA MASS GRAVE

New Srebrenica mass grave discovered

The grave is located near the hamlet of Vidikovac, in Srebrenica's surroundings.
SLANT EYES

Judge dismisses Miley Cyrus 'slant eyes' suit

Kim's lawyer sued Cyrus, 16, under a statute that prohibits businesses from discriminating...

ADS
------------------








Copyright © 2006-2009 Javno.com   All rights reserved.